LUTC Meeting Minutes 2019-04-08

DRAFT- not yet approved

Minutes submitted by Allan Rudwick (recorder)

Started at 7pm. In attendance: Committee: Brad, Allan, Jonathan, Public: Monique, Zach. Developer: Marc, architect- didn’t get name. Kat from PSU.

– 3019 NE MLK development. (60)

  • 2 buildings – one on MLK and one behind with a pathway on the north side. Each building would have 2 1-floor units per building, 1 double-height unit on top.
  • Members were excited that something might be built on the site.
  • Design seemed to be relatively well done given the amazing amount of site constraints
  • Bike parking seemed like it was being forced onto the front of the building in a strange way that has no examples elsewhere
  • Street side ground floor unit- could it be a live/work space?
  • Full disclosure: developer currently lives next door to Allan.

– Other updates? (parking permit, N/S Neighborhood Greenway on 7th or 9th Ave, improving intersections around Tubman, revamping Rodney greenway, state housing bills) (15)

  • short discussions, nothing major to report

Motion: Add 2 members to the committee. Passed 3-0 (this has been ratified by the ENA Board)

  • Monique Gaskins, Zach

8:25 Approve Minutes (5)

  • minutes approved 3-0

LUTC Meeting Minutes 2017-06-12

Eliot Neighborhood Association

Land Use and Transportation Committee

Meeting Minutes from June 12, 2017, respectively submitted by Allan Rudwick, Chair

Meeting was called to order by Chair Allan Rudwick at 7:03 PM

A quorum of the Committee was present at times, including Clint, Allan, Phil, Laurie and Montserrat.  Also preset were several residents and representatives from All USA Architecture and Bridge Housing.

Continue reading LUTC Meeting Minutes 2017-06-12

LUTC Meeting Minutes 2017-04-10

Eliot Neighborhood Association

Land Use and Transportation Committee

Meeting Minutes from April 10, 2016, respectively submitted by Mike Warwick, Vice-Chair

Meeting was called to order by Chair Allan Rudwick at 7:10 PM

A quorum of the Committee was present, including Clint, Allan, Phil, Laurie and myself.  Also preset were Nan Stark from Planning and residents Rebecca, Sara, and Ian.

Continue reading LUTC Meeting Minutes 2017-04-10

LUTC Minutes 2017-01-09

Eliot Neighborhood Association

Land Use Committee

Minutes for January 9th, 2017

DRAFT-not yet approved



a) 829 N Russell Street (Otak) proposing: 5-story shared housing project with 79 “micro-studios” and 14 common kitchens. A 800-900 square foot retail/commercial space will be located along the Russell St frontage.   The site has a sewer running diagonally across it so they have a angled front entrance with a space for a coffee shop or similar retail space.  The rest of the building is taken up by 1 room apartments 280-330 sq ft, 3 kitchens per floor and a small bike room on the ground floor for 20 bikes.  There were concerns on the committee about pricing — how can it be affordable if the rooms are going for $900 — $3/sq ft and some comments about how value engineering might take out all of the nice things they showed at the end.  There was a concern that with no car parking and very limited car parking the residents would take quite a bite out of available street parking in the area.  We were told that the target demographic is a young one that targets “experiences” over material goods and are very transit/bike/walk friendly.  It was mentioned how great it is to bike in the area when really it is not close to much without climbing a large hill.

b) The units are grouped such that the developer can claim there are six bedrooms for each kitchen, so 14 “units” rather than 79.  The committee viewed this as misrepresentative of the project and possibly a way to end run building requirements that would apply to a 70 “unit” building, although none of the members present had sufficient knowledge to know if that was the case.  Concern was also expressed that this “product” may miss the market as the Millennial generation’s demographic “bulge” will pass before it is completed.  In addition, it is relatively isolated from amenities and zoning on surrounding industrial properties won’t allow much additional development to provide those amenities.  The developer indicated they expect the units to appeal to bike-only residents who will leave the area for services along Mississippi. Otherwise, the comments on building design were very favorable, which some concern that the building may mislead prospective tenants into thinking it was more luxurious inside that it will be in fact.  Concern was also raised about the density of units in an area which has the highest air pollution in the city.  The developer was unaware of this fact and will recommend attention be paid to air filtration.  

2. Air Pollution – major diesel operators in Eliot with unfiltered engines- should we push this issue & who wants to champion?

The top 2 unfiltered diesel operators in Eliot are:

      Union Pacific Railroad Co. #trucks 12 1619 N River St
      CalPortland #trucks 183 1050 N River St

NECN is having a meeting on Wednesday the 19th and it seems like a city-wide effort is going to be required to change the rules about diesel operation.  There were some in the room who would like to hear more, and it seems that this issue is not a good one for the Land Use & Transportation committee to take up so it will see life in another arena.  To Be Continued

NECN report here:

LUTC Minutes 2016-12-12

Eliot Neighborhood Association

Land Use Committee

Minutes for December 12th, 2016

DRAFT-not yet approved


  1. Neighborhood contact from project(s) on N Williams and N Fargo — (Currently People’s Pig, an abandoned house and bluehouse green house)
    1. The proposed project will be L-shaped, with the long leg fronting North Cook across from the new apartments at 115 Cook and abutting the new Century apartment building. The short leg will extend south along Williams to the Solterra site.  The L shape creates an interior courtyard.  The building as proposed will be six stories (5-over-1) as are other nearby projects.  Retail spaces will be on the ground floor and 70 housing units are planned with 30 underground parking spaces.  The top (sixth) floor is planned to have distinctive features so it will appeal as penthouse apartment space.  The committee was generally receptive to the proposal while Ken was present.  Afterwards concerns were voiced regarding elements of the sixth-floor design and material use.  
    2. Diagonally adjacent to boarded up house on N Fargo.  Proposal to turn this abandoned house into a 4-story building with ground floor almost entirely taken up to store 4 cars.  Allan mentioned that this seems like a waste of space although other LUTC folks seemed to think that all off-street parking is good regardless of how space-inefficient
    3. History of the site: The Parker’s are long-time black owners of this property, Ms. Parker is proceeding with development planning.  She also owns a house on the block fronting North Fargo and a site on NE Cook, where her new home is being constructed.  Her properties on this block are surrounded by other new apartment development proposals and she continues to be pressured by realtors and developers to sell out to white developers.  If this development proceeds, it will be the first major development by a black property owner in Eliot.  The architect for this project is Ken Moholt-Siebert, who used to live in NE Portland, but moved to California to take over a small family farm.  Nevertheless, he continues to work for clients in the area.  He is also working with the owner on her new residence and plans for development of her other lot in this block.
    4. The property is currently zoned Rx; however, Eliot requested it be downzoned to Rh.  That, and the fact surrounding properties are being developed to Rx density, spurred this large apartment proposal at this time.
  2. Discussion about #24 bus continuing to NW Portland and advocacy surrounding early implementation (Sherifa Roach)
    1. LUTC approved signing on to a letter which hasn’t been finalized yet supporting the extension of the #24 ASAP.
  3. Comp plan update – possible letter proposing to support Institutional zone plan (Allan)
    1. people were supportive of writing a letter re:Institutional zoning with the specifics that it would enable Emanual to build on land that they have been neglecting due to the restrictions in the IMP

Adjourned around 8:45pm